Marco Island Restaurants - Top 10 Places to Eat
August 17th 2022
Many people may think there’s no way that such a small island can have so many options when it comes to dining, but that’s not the case! Marco Island is actually known for its plethora of restaurants, serving up a wide variety of fresh food and drinks. If you’re feeling overwhelmed with the amount of restaurants there are to choose from, have no fear! TripShock is here with the best Marco Island restaurants, including the top 10 places to eat!
Table of Contents
- Doreen’s Cup of Joe
- CJ’s on the Bay
- Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant
- Sale e Pepe
- The Oyster Society
- La Tavola Restaurant & Bar
- Quinn’s on the Beach
- Mango’s Dockside Bistro
- The Deck at 560
- Bistro Soleil at the Olde Marco Inn
1. Doreen’s Cup of Joe
Couple enjoys a delicious breakfast at Doreen’s Cup of Joe, a Marco Island restaurant
One of the top things to do in Marco Island, FL, breakfast at Doreen’s Cup of Joe is a must! Doreen’s is a family-owned spot, adored by both locals and visitors alike, that puts a unique twist on your typical breakfast/brunch outing. While the essentials like bacon and eggs, omelets, and breakfast sandwiches are available, menu items like key lime pancakes and cannoli stuffed French toast, makes Doreen’s unlike any other restaurant you’ll find on the island.
Another great thing about Doreen’s Cup of Joe is their commitment to using the best products. This breakfast joint prides themselves on using the freshest ingredients, to create the best experience possible for their guests. For example, they only use Eggland’s Best cage free brown eggs, pure maple Vermont syrup, and, of course, the orange juice is made from fresh squeezed Florida oranges! It is recommended to arrive early to get a table!
Address: 267 N. Collier Boulevard, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-394-2600
2. CJ’s on the Bay
Image courtesy of CJ’s on the Bay
CJ’s on the Bay is another iconic Marco Island restaurant, where patrons can get the true Florida experience! They are known for their award-winning blue cheese potato chips and fantastic fresh seafood, but their large menu also has salads, burgers, pizza, and more, so even the pickiest eaters will be pleased at CJ’s. Perks of dining at CJ’s include:
- Daily happy hour and drink specials
- Marco Island’s largest outdoor gazebo bar
- Amazing views
- Free WiFi
- Air-conditioned indoor bar with flat screen televisions and a projection screen
- Boat access
Their location right along the beautiful Smokehouse Bay makes them the perfect spot for those on a Marco Island day trip/excursion by boat, as you can pull your vessel right up, enjoy a bite to eat, and continue cruising through the South Florida waterways. Not only that, it’s the perfect place to catch the sunset, and to take in the gorgeous landscapes and scenic views of the area.
Address: 740 N. Collier Boulevard #105, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-389-4511
3. Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant
Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant is known for serving up the finest cuts of USDA Prime beef
Marco Prime is more than just one of the top Marco Island restaurants, it’s an occasion! Locally owned and operated, this spectacular steakhouse prides itself on creating a dining experience that combines excellent service, delicious food, an amazing atmosphere, and an extensive wine list and cocktail menu. Speaking of wine, let’s not forget to mention that Marco Prime has a custom wine cellar, and offers an exclusive collection of wine recognized by Wine Spectator Magazine!
While the libations, location, atmosphere, and service is top-notch, the main reason to try this awesome Marco Island restaurant is definitely the food! Prime steaks, fresh, local seafood, and the best ingredients make for a memorable and mouth-watering meal everyone will love. Perfect for celebrations, date night, or a girls’ night out, Marco Prime is the place to be for great food and great times!
Address: 599 S. Collier Boulevard, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-389-2333
4. Sale e Pepe
Marco Island restaurant, Sale e Pepe, takes pride in serving made-from-scratch meals with the freshest ingredients
If you’re in the mood for some delicious Italian food, then Sale e Pepe is the place to be to satisfy your craving! Sale e Pepe is a fine dining, award-winning Marco Island restaurant that has a setting as spectacular as the food. Overlooking the Gulf of Mexico, this is the perfect place to enjoy a romantic meal and catch the sunset with your sweetie.
Using the freshest, finest ingredients, Sale e Pepe creates mouth watering made-from-scratch meals, offering everything from ravioli to risotto! Patrons also love the wide selection of wines from Italy, craft beers, and cocktails, as well. Combine this with their marble floors and hand-painted art, and you’ll feel as if you’ve been transported to Italy!
Address: 480 S. Collier Boulevard, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-393-1600
5. The Oyster Society
Delicious oysters from Marco Island restaurant, The Oyster Society
With all of this quick and easy access to fresh and delicious local seafood, you may be asking yourself, “Where is Marco Island, FL?” Surrounded by the gorgeous waters of the Gulf of Mexico, Marco Island restaurants are known for serving up scrumptious seafood, and The Oyster Society is no different! Boasting local, hand-picked seafood, this Marco Island restaurant knows how to utilize its location and resources.
Address: 599 S. Collier Boulevard #218, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-394-3474
Not only is The Oyster Society delicious, its 1920s-themed decor creates an ambiance like no other place on the island. You’ll feel as if you’re a character in “The Great Gatsby!” The live jazz music definitely adds to the aesthetic, and can be enjoyed Friday through Sunday night. If you’re looking for more live music in Marco Island, check out one of the popular restaurants below:
6. La Tavola Restaurant & Bar
La Tavola Restaurant & Bar is known for its integration of casual and upscale food options. Image by latavolarestaurantandbar.com.
La Tavola Restaurant has a variety of delicious food options, but its casual-upscale combination is what makes them stand out from the rest. If you’re craving something casual, try the crispy fish sandwich or the beef sliders. For something fancier, try the mushroom pappardelle or pan-seared scallops and crispy pork belly. Sip on some wine from their comprehensive menu as you listen to live music by amazing artists.
Address: 961 Winterberry Dr, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-393-4960
7. Quinn’s on the Beach
If you’ve worked up an appetite after enjoying an unforgettable eco tour with AquaTerra Excursions, then head to Quinn’s on the Beach for burgers and other delicious food that can tame even the most extreme hunger
Quinn’s on the Beach is the quintessential beachside eatery, boasting stunning Gulf views in a casual setting. Their Caribbean-style meals are the perfect complement to any tropical beach vacation! Seafood, steak, sandwiches, and pizza are just a few of the many delicious menu items, creating options for even the pickiest eaters. Not only that, a LIVE fire dancing show takes place every night, meaning patrons can enjoy dinner, and a show!
Address: 400 S. Collier Boulevard, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-394-2511
8. Mango’s Dockside Bistro
Image of the view from Mango’s courtesy of Mango’s Dockside Bistro
Mango’s Dockside Bistro is another delicious, locally owned and operated Marco Island restaurant. Known for its family-friendly atmosphere, delicious food, amazing views, 750-gallon saltwater fish tank, and more, Mango’s is definitely a must when in Marco Island. While they specialize in serving up fresh seafood, Mango’s also has tasty steaks, salads, and more!
Address: 760 N. Collier Boulevard #109, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-393-2433
9. The Deck at 560
Image of the gorgeous view from The Deck at 560 courtesy of Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort & Spa
Located within the Hilton Marco Island Beach Resort & Spa, The Deck at 560 has mouth watering eats like filet mignon, fresh fish, lobster, and more! Their delicious food is created by the talented Executive Chef Corey Hepburn, using local and sustainable ingredients.
While most people come for the flavorful food, they keep coming back for the breathtaking views. This incredible Marco Island restaurant overlooks the gorgeous Gulf of Mexico, and is one of the best places to catch a sunset, relax while bird-watching and enjoy the native wildlife, and take in all the scenic beauty this island oasis has to offer!
Address: 560 S. Collier Boulevard, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-394-5000
10. Bistro Soleil at the Olde Marco Inn
Image courtesy of https://www.bistrosoleil.net/
If you’re looking for a unique dining experience that combines history, culture, and culinary arts, then Bistro Soleil at the Olde Marco Inn is the place to go. Based out of a historic building that dates back to 1883, Bistro Soleil is an iconic Marco Island restaurant that serves up fantastic French cuisine. French native and Head Chef Denis Meurgue is known for his French food with Mediterranean, Mexican, European, and Caribbean influences. Not only that, with a full bar, Gulf views, and live entertainment, a night at Bistro Soleil is sure to be one you won’t soon forget!
Address: 100 Palm Street, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone Number: 239-389-0981
As you can see, when visiting Marco Island, FL, diving in to delicious local dishes is just as important as hitting the beach and exploring the canals and waterways. With so many amazing Marco Island restaurants utilizing fresh, local ingredients, and taking pride in their product, you’re sure to end your vacation to this island oasis both full and satisfied! From fresh oysters at The Oyster Society, to prime steaks at Marco Prime, there’s something for every craving and flavor in Marco Island, FL!
Marco Island News
Keeping you informed